Brain InjuriesTraumatic Brain InjuryWhat Compensation Can You Recover After a Traumatic Brain Injury in California?

October 21, 2026

Hospital invoices, rehabilitation schedules and an employer’s leave paperwork make the early costs of a serious brain injury easy to count, yet the larger figures often belong to years that have not happened yet, such as ongoing therapy, supervision at home and a working life that may look very different from the one planned. California law allows a jury to consider both the losses already suffered and those a person is reasonably certain to face, and the way each category is proven tends to determine how a claim is valued. This article explains how that works for traumatic brain injuries, drawing on results Scarlett Law Group has published to show how the categories appear in real verdicts and settlements.

What damages may be available after a traumatic brain injury in California?

California law generally separates economic losses, such as medical expenses and lost earnings, from non-economic losses, such as physical pain, mental suffering and loss of enjoyment of life, and California’s official civil jury instructions describe how jurors are directed to approach each. In a serious brain injury claim the categories usually considered include:

  • Past and future medical care, including rehabilitation, therapy and any attendant or assisted care
  • Past lost earnings and reduced future earning capacity
  • Pain, mental suffering, emotional distress and loss of enjoyment of life

Which categories apply, and in what amounts, depends on the injury, the evidence and whether negligence can be established against each defendant.

Can future medical treatment and long-term care be included in a TBI claim?

Yes, where the evidence shows the care is reasonably certain to be needed, which is the standard California applies to the reasonable cost of necessary treatment in the future. Rehabilitation, therapy and long-term assistance can all fall within that category in brain injury claims when physicians and life care planners can explain what the person will require and why.

The firm’s published results for brain injury clients show how large the future care component can become, reporting that a San Jose jury’s roughly $49.1 million verdict in 2009 included $27.6 million for future medical expenses, against $3.4 million for past medical expenses, in a case where the plaintiff’s injuries were described as requiring lifelong round-the-clock care. Because past results do not guarantee a similar outcome, the figures are offered only to show how the categories can be itemised by a jury.

How is lost future earning capacity calculated after a brain injury?

Where lost earning capacity is claimed, vocational experts and economists may compare what the person was likely to earn before the injury with what they may realistically earn afterwards, drawing on material such as work history, education, cognitive testing and vocational assessment, and the difference can be expressed in present value terms. Methods vary from case to case, and California treats lost earnings and lost earning capacity as related but separate concepts, so the evidence needed depends on the person’s circumstances and may be detailed when a brain injury affects the ability to work.

Returning to work is often harder than families expect, since in a Model Systems study of 320 people with moderate-to-severe injuries who were working when injured, under 40 percent were employed a year later. Scarlett Law Group reports a 2011 California jury award of about $10.65 million in a brain injury case that included $2,526,543 for diminished earning capacity, and past results do not guarantee similar outcomes.

Can compensation account for cognitive and behavioural changes?

Yes, through the non-economic category, which covers mental suffering, emotional distress and loss of enjoyment of life, and through the economic categories when those changes limit work or require supervision. California gives jurors no formula for non-economic damages, so testimony from the injured person, relatives, treating clinicians and neuropsychologists about changes in memory, mood, judgement or personality can carry considerable weight.

In the same 2011 verdict the jury awarded $2.5 million for past and $3 million for future non-economic damages, an example of how such losses can be recognised separately from medical bills.

Why can some traumatic brain injury cases result in substantial awards?

Awards grow large when an injury creates needs that last for decades, because future care, supervision and reduced earning capacity are each projected across the person’s life rather than a few years, which makes evidence about life expectancy and likely independence central. Fault allocation also matters because California juries assign each responsible party a percentage of fault, which affects what each defendant owes. In the 2009 verdict described above, the jury divided fault among two truck drivers and the State of California.

Does every traumatic brain injury claim have the same value?

No, because two people with the same diagnosis can have very different outcomes once severity, occupation, medical needs, the strength of the liability evidence and available insurance are taken into account, and a claim’s value cannot responsibly be estimated without those details. Scarlett Law Group’s reported results illustrate the range of outcomes in individual cases but are not a guide to what another claim will achieve, and an attorney can assess a specific situation after reviewing the records.

Frequently asked questions

Does it matter whether the injury happened in San Francisco or Larkspur?

Damages rules come from California law, so the same categories apply in either place, although the county where a case is filed, usually where the injury occurred or where a defendant is based, determines which court hears it. Scarlett Law Group lists offices in San Francisco and Larkspur, so injured clients and families in either area have a nearby point of contact.

Can I still recover if I was partly at fault for the accident?

Often yes, because California applies comparative fault, which generally reduces a person’s recovery by their share of responsibility rather than barring it altogether. The percentage assigned depends on the evidence, which is why an attorney should review the facts before any admission is made or offer accepted.

Should I accept an early settlement offer after a brain injury?

Early offers are often made before the full extent of cognitive, physical and financial effects is known, and accepting one usually means signing a release that gives up further claims arising from the incident against the parties it names, including for needs that only emerge later. It is wise to understand likely future needs before agreeing to anything. A brain injury attorney can review an offer against the medical evidence, explain what the release covers and what the payment may not, and say whether the injured person’s prognosis is clear enough yet for any figure to be considered reliable.

Discussing your own circumstances

Anyone dealing with a serious brain injury is welcome to talk through their situation with Scarlett Law Group, which can review the records and explain which losses may apply without suggesting any particular outcome.

The cost of a brain injury runs well past the first hospital bills, and a claim should account for all of it. Our experienced lawyers at the Scarlett Law Group can document what long-term care and lost income look like for your family and pursue the compensation you need.

Visit our offices at 540 Pacific Avenue, San Francisco, CA 94133.

Or call now for a free consultation at (415) 352-6264.

https://www.scarlettlawgroup.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/phone3.png

If You Or Someone You Love Has Been Injured In An Accident, Contact Us Today

OUR LOCATIONS

Disclaimer: This website contains Attorney Advertising and is designed for informational purposes only. Any information obtained should not be construed to be formal legal advice nor the formation of a lawyer/client relationship. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome and some results included co-console. Some of our offices are satellite offices/not fully staffed 24/7.

Copyright© Scarlett Law Group Injury and Accident Attorneys 2026